Eleanor Blair (lnr) wrote,
Eleanor Blair

20: Master and Commander: Patrick O'Brian: ISBN 0-00-715786-X

Am I strange for leaping on the bandwagon and buying a newly released edition of a book with a picture from the film that's just been made of it on the front of the book when I haven't even seen the film yet? Lots of people raved about the film, and I like reading, and the book was on 3 for 2 in Borders, and well there we are.

I found it a little slow to get going at first, and oddly disjointed in places. It has a habit of skipping the boring bits and going on to the next bit that's happening, which is fair enough - in a sea-going thing like this there's going to be a lot of just getting from A to B with not much happening. It just does it in a slightly odd way which took me a while to get used to. Instead of just saying "Nothing much happened for a bit" and then going on it tends to just leap forward over the gap and talk of what's happening now and just throw in a quick "nothing much happened since the last thing, did it" after the fact.

I enjoyed it anyway. It's a good yarn, and I expect if I were to read more of them I'd enjoy them too, not to mention find them easier going as I get more to grips with the naval terms used. Having one of the characters be a non-Navy chap on-board and learning them himself did help. Not entirely sure I sympathise entirely with any of the characters, though many of them are likeable, perhaps I like Stephen best. Jack Aubrey himself is just a bit too, something, flighty, over-enthusiastic, I don't know. And of course it's a bit short on women, but that's only to be expected. The historical detail I am told is fascinating and accurate: to me it simply pleased by being convincing and not too intrusive.

I feel like I'm damning with terribly faint praise here, but can't find anything more throughly positive to say. Still, I'd like to see the film some time. But maybe I should try and read the rest of the books up to and including the other one in the series that the film was based on first :-)

  • You say goodbye?

    And I say hello! I've been having a bit of a friends-list tidy, with the intention of removing everyone who either no longer posts anything, or who…

  • Time for migration

    Livejournal's new Terms of Service (which I've had to agree to in order to read about them and post this) are not to my taste. I've been here a long…

  • Thoughts on abortion on International Women's Day

    Larissa Nolan writes in the Irish Times about being a non-religious pro-life supporter in the current climate, and how she finds the rhetoric of…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.